| Year |
Horse |
Statistics |
Sire - Dam - Dam's Sire |
Family No. |
| 1883 | Leonatus (USA) | b.c. 1880 | Longfellow (USA) - Semper Felix (USA) by Phaeton (GB) | 12 - b |
| 1884 | Audrain (USA) | ch.c. 1881 | Springbok (USA) - Alme (USA) by Planet (USA) | 23 - b |
| 1885 | Bersan (USA) | b.c. 1882 | Ten Broeck (USA) - Sallie M. (USA) by Longfellow (USA) | A3 |
| 1886 | Silver Cloud (USA) | b.c. 1883 | Grinstead (USA) - Experiment by Monarchist | A14 |
| 1887 | Libretto (USA) | b.c. 1884 | Longfellow (USA) - Allegretto (USA) by Bonnie Scotland (GB) | 2 - a |
| 1888* | Los Angeles (USA) | ch.f. 1885 | Glenelg (USA) - La Polka (USA) by Lexington (USA) | 23 - b |
| 1889 | Hindoocraft (USA) | b.c. 1886 | Hindoo (USA) - Lady Crafton (USA) by Fellowcraft (USA) | -- |
| 1890 | Bill Letcher (USA) | b.c. 1887 | Longfellow (USA) - Ida Lewis (USA) by Brigadier (FR) | A22 |
| 1891 | Kingman (USA) | b.c. 1888 | Glengarry 2 (GB) - Patricia (USA) by Vauxhall (USA) | 23 - b |
| 1892 | Newton (USA) | b.c. 1889 | Billet (GB) - Vassar (USA) by Virgil (USA) | 4 - r |
| 1893 | Buck McCann (USA) | ch.c. 1890 | Buchanan (USA) - Mollie Mccann (USA) by Hunter's Lexington (USA) | -- |
| 1894 | Lazzarone (USA) | ch.c. 1891 | Spendthrift (USA) - Spinaway (USA) by Leamington (GB) | 11 |
| 1895 | Halma (USA) | bl.c. 1892 | Hanover (USA) - Julia L. (USA) by Longfellow (USA) | 4 - r |
| 1896 | Ben Brush (USA) | b.c. 1893 | Bramble (USA) - Roseville (USA) by Reform (USA) | A1 |
| 1897 | Ornament (USA) | ch.c. 1894 | Order (GB) - Victorine (USA) by Onondaga (USA) | 12 - b |
| 1898 | Han d'Or (USA) | ch.c. 1895 | Hanover (USA) - Fleur d'Or (USA) by Rayon d'Or (FR) | 12 - b |
| 1899 | Prince McClurg (USA) | br.c. 1896 | Wadsworth (USA) - Minnie Payne (USA) by Bannach Lath (USA) | -- |
| 1900 | Lieut. Gibson (USA) | br.c. 1897 | G.W. Johnson (USA) - Sophia Hardy (USA) by Glengarry (GB) | A13 |
| 1901 | Hernando (USA) | b.c. 1898 | Hanover (USA) - Retrieve (USA) by Duke Of Montrose (USA) | A23 |
| 1902 | Harry New (USA) | bl.c. 1899 | Pirate of Penzance (GB) - Barcelona (USA) by Hindoo (USA) | 32 |
| 1903 | Woodlake (USA) | ch.c. 1900 | Candlemas (GB) - Bracegirdle (USA) by Fonso (USA) | A1 |
| 1904 | Elwood (USA) | b.c. 1901 | Free Knight (USA) - Petticoat (USA) by Alarm (USA) | 5 - g |
| 1905 | The Foreman (USA) | ch.c. 1902 | Inspector B (USA) - Nitetis (USA) by Great Tom (GB) | 5 - a |
| 1906 | Sir Huon (USA) | b.c. 1903 | Falsetto (USA) - Ignite (USA) by Woodlands (GB) | 5 - g |
| 1907 | The Abbot (USA) | b.c. 1904 | The Friar (USA) - Goody Good (USA) by Lamplighter (USA) | 12 - b |
| 1908 | Pinkola (USA) | c. 1905 | Pink Coat (USA) - Wyola (USA) by Wawekus (USA) | A13 |
| 1909 | Olambala (USA) | ch.c. 1906 | Ornus (GB) - Blue And White (USA) by Virgil (USA) | 21 - a |
| 1910 | Joe Morris (USA) | b.c. 1907 | Peep o' Day (GB) - Hanoverine (USA) by Hanover (USA) | A1 |
| 1911 | Governor Gray (USA) | b.g. 1908 | Garry Herrmann (USA) - Salama (USA) by Himyar (USA) | 12 - b |
| 1912 | Free Lance (USA) | ch.c. 1909 | Alvescot (GB) - Merry Hart by Sir Modred (NZ) | 6 |
| 1913 | Gowell (USA) | ch.f. 1910 | Ort Wells (USA) - Responsive (USA) by Mirthful (USA) | 23 - b |
| 1914 | John Gund (USA) | b.c. 1911 | Peep o' Day (GB) - My Gyps (USA) by Kyrle Daly (GB) | 12 - b |
| 1915 | Royal II (GB) | b.c. 1912 | Your Majesty (GB) - Lady Ethel (GB) by Sir Geoffrey (GB) | 5 - d |
| 1916 | Dodge (USA) | b.c. 1913 | Jim Gaffney (USA) - Flora Willoughby (USA) by Florist (GB) | 40 |
| 1917 | Liberty Loan (USA) | br.c. 1914 | Dick Finnell (USA) - Martha Palmer (USA) by Sempronius (GB) | 2 - h |
| 1918 | Johren (GB) | b.c. 1915 | Spearmint (GB) - Mineola (USA) by Meddler (GB) | 2 - h |
| 1919 | Be Frank (USA) | b.g. 1916 | Sir John Johnson (USA) - Frankness (USA) by Miller (USA) | 4 - m |
| 1920 | Upset (USA) | ch.c. 1917 | Whiskbroom (USA) - Pankhurst (USA) by Voter (GB) | 9 - b |
| 1921 | Brother Batch (USA) | b.c. 1918 | Vulcain (FR) - Barbie (USA) by Orlando (GB) | 4 - m |
| 1922 | Thibodaux (USA) | ch.c. 1919 | Cunard (USA) - Electro (USA) by Electioneer (USA) | 14 - e |
| 1923 | The Clown (USA) | c. 1920 | Hessian (USA) - Witfull (USA) by Mirthful (USA) | 23 - b |
| 1924 | Chilhowee (USA) | b.c. 1921 | Ballot (USA) - Bourbon Lass (USA) by Bourbon Beau (USA) | 21 |
| 1925 | Broadway Jones (USA) | b.c. 1922 | Black Toney (USA) - Vaila (GB) by Fariman (IRE) | 8 - f |
| 1926 | Bagenbaggage (USA) | ch.c. 1923 | Under Fire (GB) - Blushing Beauty (USA) by Cunard (USA) | A27 |
| 1927 | Handy Mandy (USA) | b.f. 1924 | Brown Prince (GB) - Mandy Hamilton (GB) by John o' Gaunt (GB) | 32 |
| 1928 | Toro (USA) | b.c. 1925 | The Porter (USA) - Brocatelle (GB) by Radium (GB) | 2 - o |
| 1929 | Buddy Basil (USA) | ch.c. 1926 | Basil (USA) - Eris (USA) by Thunderer (USA) | 9 - e |
| 1930 | Gallant Knight (USA) | br.c. 1927 | Bright Knight (GB) - Ethel Gray (USA) by Hessian (USA) | 2 - s |
| 1931 | Spanish Play (USA) | b.c. 1928 | Spanish Prince (GB) - Anna Horton (USA) by Wrack (GB) | 4 - r |
| 1932 | Stepenfetchit (USA) | ch.c. 1929 | The Porter (USA) - Sobranje by Polymelus (GB) | 2 - e |
| 1933 | Gold Basis (USA) | b.c. 1930 | Dis Donc (FR) - Pretty Puss (USA) by The Manager (USA) | 4 - r |
| 1934 | Fiji (USA) | br.f. 1931 | Bostonian (USA) - O Girl (USA) by Ormondale (USA) | 3 - n |
| 1935 | Tearout (USA) | br.c. 1932 | Terry (USA) - Rail On (USA) by On Watch (USA) | 19 - b |
| 1936 | Rushaway (USA) | bl.c. 1933 | Haste (USA) - Roseway (GB) by Stornoway (GB) | 1 - s |
| 1937 | Reaping Reward (USA) | br.c. 1934 | Sickle (USA) - Dustwhirl (USA) by Sweep (USA) | 8 - h |
